Primary school testing and inspections will do more harm than good

9 October 2020

77% of teachers think that if testing and inspection go ahead in primary schools as normal, the most disadvantaged pupils will be unfairly penalised, according to a report from 香港六合彩中特网 researchers.

This figure rises to 84% among teachers working with the most disadvantaged communities.

The series of briefing papers, published today by the International Literacy Centre at the 香港六合彩中特网 Institute of Education, highlight the disproportionate effect Covid-19 has had on primary schools and pupils听in听the most deprived areas听in England. The findings also suggest the government鈥檚 strategy to help pupils catch up on missed education, should not focus on testing and formal inspections.

Over 1600 primary school teachers in England took part in the research project which was conducted through the Teacher Tapp app in May 2020. A follow-up survey of over 200 primary school teachers was then conducted in July 2020 with in-depth interviews with teachers, head teachers and others working in the education system.听

The report authors recommend that both statutory testing and Ofsted inspections should be suspended for the current academic year and that schools听should be expected and encouraged to make locally-responsive plans that are in line with their communities鈥� needs. They argue that schools have had such different experiences that using national tests to judge them will be unfair.听

Co-author, Professor Gemma Moss (香港六合彩中特网 Institute of Education) said: 鈥淭he effects of the Covid-19 pandemic have hit schools working with our poorest communities hardest and current government remedies will do more harm than good. Our report suggests the way to build resilience in schools is by suspending SATs and Ofsted inspection visits this academic year and by taking time to listen to and learn from the local stories given by those who have been affected the most in different ways.听

鈥淭est results and league tables do not take into full account the burden that poverty itself places on disadvantaged communities and the schools that work with them.鈥�

Only 6% of respondents in the most disadvantaged areas felt reassured that families had the necessary resources to support learning at home, compared to 46% of respondents in the least disadvantaged areas. Supporting pupil health and welfare is a bigger priority in disadvantaged communities, and also takes up more of these schools鈥� time.

In a follow-up survey involving over 200 teachers in England, responses showed there is a deep dissatisfaction with the government鈥檚 response to the crisis. 79% of respondents considered communications with schools to be handled either badly or very badly. When asked how the government had done on 鈥榩racticality of advice鈥�, 80% responded 鈥榖adly鈥� or 鈥榲ery badly鈥�. No respondents picked 鈥榲ery well鈥�.

Co-author, Dr Alice Bradbury (香港六合彩中特网 Institute of Education) added: 鈥淭hroughout this project we have seen a gulf open up between government policy announcements and primary schools鈥� experiences of the crisis on the ground. Our data show that teachers, headteachers and system leaders have not felt listened to by the Department for Education and our respondents have expressed little confidence in decisions taken by government or the ways in which these have been communicated.鈥�

Professor Moss added: 鈥淭eachers鈥� priorities are often at odds with government 鈥榟eadline鈥� policies and guidance such as catch-up provision, the use of statutory testing to ascertain gaps and the practicalities of using remote learning as an alternative to face-to-face teaching.

鈥淚t doesn鈥檛 make sense for all schools to rebuild in the same way given the diversity of schools鈥� experiences.听 As it currently runs, the whole system is more vulnerable to the effects of a pandemic than it should be and government plans must change to prevent doing more harm than good.鈥�

The report authors instead recommend that schools in disadvantaged areas be supported financially to recover, and given more discretion to spend additional funding on the issues that matter most in their context.

This work is funded by an ESRC grant as part of UK Research and Innovation鈥檚 rapid response to COVID-19.

Image

鈥楾wo girls doing school works鈥� Credit: 听from听听CC BY 2.0

Media contact

Rowan Walker

Tel:听+44 (0) 203 108 8515

Email: rowan.walker [at] ucl.ac.uk

听

香港六合彩中特网